Print Page | Close Window

Oil Pressure Temporarily Drops On Acceleration

Printed From: TheAMCForum.com
Category: The Garage
Forum Name: AMC V8 Engine Repair and Modifications
Forum Description: AMC-made V8 engine mechanical, ignition and fuel from basic repair to high-perf modifications
URL: https://theamcforum.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=115467
Printed Date: Apr/23/2024 at 10:03pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.03 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Oil Pressure Temporarily Drops On Acceleration
Posted By: Rebel Machine
Subject: Oil Pressure Temporarily Drops On Acceleration
Date Posted: May/13/2022 at 7:02pm
Got a strange thing happening with my AMX. When rolling along slowly I'll drop it in 1st and stomp the gas. About one second afterwards the oil pressure drops from 56 lbs to 40 lbs for a split second then the pressure recovers. It's never done this before. I've got seven quarts of oil in a Canton eight quart pan. Also has a windage tray.

I find it hard to believe in that short time the pan gets emptied into the valve covers. This engine wraps RPM pretty quickly as it's supercharged.

Possibly the overpressure valve is opening too far? Maybe the oil is aerating somehow?

Ideas anyone?

Thanks,
-Steve-




Replies:
Posted By: Boris Badanov
Date Posted: May/14/2022 at 7:39am
Oil stacking up at the back of the oil pan is the likely culprit.
My guess is the pick up needs to be a tad closer to the rear of the pan.

I would not panic.



-------------
Gremlin Dreams


Posted By: Trader
Date Posted: May/14/2022 at 7:49am
Beyond agreeing with Boris, why do you only put seven quarts of oil in an eight quart oil pan?


Posted By: BassBoat
Date Posted: May/14/2022 at 3:04pm
I saw the heading on your topic, I had exactly that problem on my AMX.  However the cure in my case was the Canton pan.  I think Boris and Trader are on the right track.  I have an old Milodon with external lines and swivel pickup that chases the oil.  440 source makes a swivel pickup that is about half the cost of the Milodon.  A pickup that swings back on accel and forward on deccel might solve your problem.



Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/14/2022 at 8:35pm
I have the Canton eight quart pan. The dipstick shows full with seven quarts. Should be more than adequate. Never had trouble with a stock pan.

This may require a teardown. Might be a few LS engines in the local salvage yard.

-Steve-





Posted By: JGRANTAMX
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 10:39am
 IIRC your engine RPM limit is about 5800? So if you bring the RPM's up a little slower and hold 5800 for a few seconds does the pressure dip? If you duplicate the quick RPM wind up in neutral from holding 3500 to 5800 does the oil pressure dip then, does it matter if you are going up or down a hill? These are some of the things I would try to narrow down the problem before taking it apart.

J


Posted By: Red Devil
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 2:32pm
Momentary pump cavitation, pressure drops, then quickly recovers?   Does it happen at a specific oil temp? 

Any changes to crankcase venting, oil grade/brand, oil filter recently?

Assuming still reading pressure at stock location after the filter?   Does it have the stock filter bypass, plugged bypass, or filter with a bypass?  Filter bypass is there to handle sudden oil surges / cold oil that the filter can't handle, to prevent starvation (pressure reading in bypass would be lower ... but pressure would have dropped already due to filter restriction for it to go into bypass).

Also of interest, the relief valve spring cavity is vented to the oil pump inlet (pump suction).   Theoretically, if the pump could momentarily pull full vacuum, the relief would open at 14.7 psi lower than normal and pressure momentarily drop.  Note the stock relief starts to crack open around 40-45 psi.  FWIW, I changed the relief spring cavity venting on my stock pump years ago to vent to crankcase instead of pump inlet, but can't say for certain if it made any improvement (shared details on Fran's Forum).

But if it only drops momentarily and quickly recovers, don't see a big concern.   Owner's manual actually says a momentary drop in pressure is normal under certain conditions - likely to keep the Service Department from being inundated by owners who notice pressure fluctuations ... and why actual gauges were eliminated in newer cars.

But if it's something new that hasn't happened before, can understand the concern.   Especially with your history of multiple engine builds chasing an ideal pressure.  Best to check for any recent changes and maybe fit a new filter as the most economical option.

Hope this helps, RD




Posted By: Trader
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 2:56pm
I have 3 dipsticks here and all are different lengths, 24" Jeep, 20-1/2" and 20-1/4" AMC. All different to full mark also, but within a 1/4".
Don't go by the dip stick unless you know absolutely it's original.
An 8 quart pan should likely have 8 quarts in it. Likely 1/4" higher then the full mark on your dipstick!
Oil pressure fluctuations are also normal, so if you want to run 7 quarts, then that's fine.



Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 3:51pm
Originally posted by JGRANTAMX JGRANTAMX wrote:

 IIRC your engine RPM limit is about 5800? So if you bring the RPM's up a little slower and hold 5800 for a few seconds does the pressure dip? If you duplicate the quick RPM wind up in neutral from holding 3500 to 5800 does the oil pressure dip then, does it matter if you are going up or down a hill? These are some of the things I would try to narrow down the problem before taking it apart.

J


Replaced the oil pressure gauge with a spare, same thing.

Took it out and tried your tests. While driving at 30 MPH I slipped it into neutral and wrapped up the RPM north of 6,000. No pressure drop.

Uphill acceleration showed a larger drop in pressure versus downhill so that suggests the rush of oil to the rear of the engine is the cause. So that being said how is it related? Aeration from the oil hitting the crank suddenly? Starvation? The pan has spring loaded internal baffling, maybe it's fallen apart?

Since the engine has the internal oil line I have to trim out the center of the intake gasket so it fits. Done this on multiple engines in the past so I doubt that's part of the problem but thought I should mention it.

Here are some reference photos.

-Steve-










Posted By: Trader
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 5:24pm
Another possibility would be rush of oil to the rear of the rocker covers and the front head oil returns are not doing anything going uphill. 
Also applies to the valley return holes.
So momentary oil starvation until oil starts returning via the front head/valley oil returns.


Posted By: JGRANTAMX
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 5:36pm
 An easy test would be add another quart of oil and see if it helps, some say a stock AMC pan can hold 6 quarts without issues maybe you can run 8 quarts.

J




Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 7:28pm
Originally posted by JGRANTAMX JGRANTAMX wrote:

 An easy test would be add another quart of oil and see if it helps, some say a stock AMC pan can hold 6 quarts without issues maybe you can run 8 quarts.

J





Tried that too. No change. Starting to wonder if this has always been happening but I simply never noticed. Also wondering if a stock type pan baffle in the Canton pan would be helpful.

-Steve-





Posted By: bwamx
Date Posted: May/15/2022 at 8:17pm
Which Canton pan is that? What pickup is used? I have a Canton deep sump but with an external pickup. 
Are there trapdoors on those baffles?  My pan has no baffling down low. I don’t have any pics but seem to remember a shelf like the stock pan at the rear of the sump. I can’t see how you could be draining the  pan on such a short rpm blip. I’ll run the 1/4 in a rpm range of 6500-7400  the whole time. No pressure drop or drain back issues. What weight oil and filter and in stock location?


-------------
73 Jav-AMX " The Black Widow"
358cu/in Crossram
T-10 9" Rear


Posted By: Jmerican
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 11:41am
Modern sticky tires? Big rubber? G-forces can be really strong these days, in a straight line or round a corner. Trick Wet sump vehicles will often exceed gravity. ( like a hot air balloon, jk ) Maybe canton came up short with the rear baffle. You mentioned supercharged, which probably adds a bit of let’s say surge under the rolling stomp you speak of. 

As others have offered, try a bump in oil level. That is easy. Sure windage blah blah, but really, your issue seems less likely to be windage or drainback. It’s an instantaneous thing, and those above mentioned things would take more steady state operation to occur. 

The oil will stack up at 45 degrees under your anti gravity launch. (@1G) and with the car lifting the front a bit, and the sudden surge, you can bet that oil slams aft and then sloshes. All while drawing serious gulps of oil from the pickup, creating a vortex that may exceed the sloped slug of oil. 

To me, the baffle you show in your pic seems inadequate, IMO.

The idea of moving the pickup aft as suggested, to me, may also be a good idea, but more difficult. Maybe canton could do better there too. Possible. 

I do think it’s possible that your relief spring is weak, and may not recover quickly once you blow it off a bit with a quick rap.



Posted By: Midnight Rambler
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 1:17pm
Originally posted by JGRANTAMX JGRANTAMX wrote:

 An easy test would be add another quart of oil and see if it helps, some say a stock AMC pan can hold 6 quarts without issues maybe you can run 8 quarts.

J




That was my thought.  I know there are a few common sticks with different full lines on them.  If the pan is 8qts, I'd do an oil change with 8 qts and put a new "full" indicator on the stick.  It would seem most likely to be that or the baffle.


-------------

'66 American 440 Convertible 290/M-40/AMC 20 3.15/PS/PB
'04 Jeep Wrangler X Rocky Mountain Edition 4.0 5sp


Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 4:29pm
Originally posted by bwamx bwamx wrote:

Which Canton pan is that? What pickup is used? I have a Canton deep sump but with an external pickup. 
Are there trapdoors on those baffles?  My pan has no baffling down low. I don’t have any pics but seem to remember a shelf like the stock pan at the rear of the sump. I can’t see how you could be draining the  pan on such a short rpm blip. I’ll run the 1/4 in a rpm range of 6500-7400  the whole time. No pressure drop or drain back issues. What weight oil and filter and in stock location?



This is the Canton pan: http://www.jegs.com/i/Canton-Racing-Products/074/15-554/10002/-1" rel="nofollow - https://www.jegs.com/i/Canton-Racing-Products/074/15-554/10002/-1

Using their pickup tube: http://www.jegs.com/i/Canton-Racing-Products/074/15-555/10002/-1" rel="nofollow - https://www.jegs.com/i/Canton-Racing-Products/074/15-555/10002/-1

I believe it has spring loaded trapdoors. 10W-30 oil. Purolator filter in the stock location.

-Steve-


Posted By: Trader
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 4:40pm
You stated 7 quarts to the full mark. The pan advertisement states 8 quart and 9 quarts with filter.
Are the 7 quarts with or without the filter?
They built the pan and doubt they would mislead on how much oil the pan holds installed on an AMC V8.


Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 4:41pm
Originally posted by Jmerican Jmerican wrote:

Modern sticky tires? Big rubber? G-forces can be really strong these days, in a straight line or round a corner. Trick Wet sump vehicles will often exceed gravity. ( like a hot air balloon, jk ) Maybe canton came up short with the rear baffle. You mentioned supercharged, which probably adds a bit of let’s say surge under the rolling stomp you speak of. 

As others have offered, try a bump in oil level. That is easy. Sure windage blah blah, but really, your issue seems less likely to be windage or drainback. It’s an instantaneous thing, and those above mentioned things would take more steady state operation to occur. 

The oil will stack up at 45 degrees under your anti gravity launch. (@1G) and with the car lifting the front a bit, and the sudden surge, you can bet that oil slams aft and then sloshes. All while drawing serious gulps of oil from the pickup, creating a vortex that may exceed the sloped slug of oil. 

To me, the baffle you show in your pic seems inadequate, IMO.

The idea of moving the pickup aft as suggested, to me, may also be a good idea, but more difficult. Maybe canton could do better there too. Possible. 

I do think it’s possible that your relief spring is weak, and may not recover quickly once you blow it off a bit with a quick rap.




Running sticky Mickey Thompson rubber, car hooks pretty good even on the street. It'll pull the front wheels and inch or so on a prepped surface.

Tried the extra quart of oil, no change.

Think I'm just gonna run it. If I hear a rod knocking I'll tear it down.

-Steve-



Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 4:46pm
When I first got the Canton pan I put water in it a quart at a time to check the level.


Four quarts:





Five quarts:





Six quarts:





Seven quarts:





Eight quarts:




Posted By: mbwicz
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 5:38pm
Don't forget that the filter is about 1/2 quart and there is a decent amount of oil in circulation while the engine is running.  I read a thread here that the oil level drops at least 1 quart while the engine is running (this was to help justify running 6 quarts in a stock pan).

So you may be running at the 6 quart level in your pictures.

I think its good that several people have indicated not to worry about it.

Mike


-------------
1970 AMX, one step forward, one step back. Both steps cost time and money.


Posted By: WesternRed
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 8:37pm
Shim the oil pressure relief spring and see what happens.

-------------
I've finally given up drinking for good...........now I only drink for evil.


Posted By: JGRANTAMX
Date Posted: May/16/2022 at 10:20pm
 I would think that because the problem changes with angle of the pan up or down hill somehow the oil level goes down enough to effect pickup, if it was my engine the concern would be what RPM does the pressure dip happen and does the oil pressure drop low enough to cause bearing wear? That engine has a windage tray I would think crank whipped aeration would be low on the list as a cause. It would be interesting to see a video of what's happening I wonder if anyone has come up with of a drain plug fitted end scope camera that would be cool.

J


Posted By: Boris Badanov
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 5:36am
  I believe if you move the pickup to the aft center corner of the pan all will be good.

-------------
Gremlin Dreams


Posted By: bwamx
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 9:06am
Nobody has asked I don't believe . Did you check or verify the location of the oil pickup to the bottom of the pan ?

-------------
73 Jav-AMX " The Black Widow"
358cu/in Crossram
T-10 9" Rear


Posted By: 68-73 amx
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 12:04pm
And you need 1/2 clearance pickup to pan with a Canton pan.


Posted By: Rebel Machine
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 3:57pm
Originally posted by bwamx bwamx wrote:

Nobody has asked I don't believe . Did you check or verify the location of the oil pickup to the bottom of the pan ?


Yes, used clay to measure and make sure it's not sitting against the bottom of the pan.

-Steve-


Posted By: Steve_P
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 6:01pm
Regardless of all the hypothesis here, 40PSI is totally sufficient. Drive and don't worry about it


Posted By: Steve_P
Date Posted: May/17/2022 at 6:03pm
Originally posted by WesternRed WesternRed wrote:

Shim the oil pressure relief spring and see what happens.

If he has 56 PSI and it drops to 40 PSI when he floors it, please explain how the pressure relief spring is an issue?  (it's not)  It was just 56 PSI two seconds prior.



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.03 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2019 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net