Print Page | Close Window

To Moog or not to Moog. That is the question

Printed From: TheAMCForum.com
Category: The Garage
Forum Name: Suspension, Steering, Brakes & Wheels
Forum Description: What makes it stop, turn, and smooths the ride
URL: https://theamcforum.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=104009
Printed Date: Apr/19/2024 at 9:02pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.03 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: To Moog or not to Moog. That is the question
Posted By: CHAR
Subject: To Moog or not to Moog. That is the question
Date Posted: Feb/12/2020 at 7:07pm
Has anyone tried and is happy or had the misfortune of installing one of these full stock front end rebuild kits with ball joints and tie rods from the bay?  Theres one listed for $180 bucks and it just states " all new quality parts".  There is a site that has a all MOOG parts kit - matchy matchy with the Bay one, but its $340.  Is this an instance of you get what you pay for, or is the cheaper set just as good?  Whats been your experience with getting front end parts?

Thanks



-------------
72 Javelin SST P code 360/auto/AC/rear defrost /Go Pack/Polar White w blue cord interior.



Replies:
Posted By: bbgjc
Date Posted: Feb/12/2020 at 8:13pm
I use tons of Moog parts and have great success with them.  I've used other brands and they crap out way too soon.   I had set of BMW balls joints go bad in 5K.



Posted By: ramblinrev
Date Posted: Feb/12/2020 at 8:52pm
Go to Rockauto and you'll probably find all MOOG parts for closer to the $180 than the $340.

-------------
74 Hornet Hatchback X twins (since 1977)
62 American Convertible (still worth the $50 I spent in 1973!) AMCRC #513, AMO #384
70 AMX 360 4-speed (since 1981)


Posted By: AMXFSTBK390
Date Posted: Feb/12/2020 at 9:17pm
I recently rebuilt the front suspension on my 68 AMX. I ordered all the parts carte blanche. I wanted Moog or TRW parts only.

-------------
Questions are powerful tools...what's in your toolbox?


Posted By: Buzzman72
Date Posted: Feb/12/2020 at 10:06pm
You can't go wrong with Moog or TRW.

Much else might be a crapshoot.



-------------
Buzzman72...void where prohibited, your mileage may vary, objects in mirror may be closer than they appear, and alcohol may intensify any side effects.


Posted By: tomj
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 12:18am
"quality" parts -- are the good quality? or bad quality?

Better to Moog than to fade away.

Parts quality is all over the place. I've been moving more and more towards quality *vendors* that will stand behind what they sell. Like Mike's Carburetors, I'm sure his carbs are chinese made, that's not the problem, Q.C. is and Mike seems to do that. RockAuto stands behind their parts -- way behind! lol kidding. They're drop-shippers, and they do take parts back, but custo serv is a bit rough. Summit is always slightly more money, but top notch large-scale vendor. Then our AMC suppliers, pricey, but you can talk on the phone to someone with the sticky part in their actual hand, and I need a rare, rare, yoke, and I'm gonna pay and pay, but I'll get the right part. Etc.


I'm wary of "kits" for cars this old. I buy a la carte. Last time I ate at a buffet I got the runs. (Seriously, don't eat the lettuce.)



-------------
1960 Rambler Super two-door wagon, OHV auto
1961 Roadster American, 195.6 OHV, T5
http://www.ramblerLore.com



Posted By: mixed up
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 12:18am
moog or trw yes I alwas get life time parts from them

-------------
69 amx 290 auto
65 220 290 4spd
80 ford fairmont


Posted By: FSJunkie
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 12:56am
Moog is the cheap stuff at NAPA. NAPA's Proformer Chassis parts are Moog. 3 year warranty.

NAPA's good stuff is their own brand called NAPA Chassis Parts, or NCP. Lifetime warranty.

Moog uses plain black rubber ball joint seals that just push over the ball stud and mush around the ball joint to seal it...poorly. NAPA Chassis Parts use blue Viton seals that are less prone to rotting and are manufactured as one peace with the ball joint for a 100% seal. Better seal = less lubrication and less contamination = longer life.

So go Moog if you want to go cheap.


-------------
1955 Packard
1966 Marlin
1972 Wagoneer
1973 Ambassador
1977 Hornet
1982 Concord D/L
1984 Eagle Limited


Posted By: Steve_P
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 6:45am
Moog is definitely not the quality it was 30 years ago. It was bought out by Federal Mogul which was then bought by Tenneco. I think that's where we are now. There's no way I would ever use a "white box" ball joint or tie rod end. I used generic ball joints one time 30 years ago and had to change them again in a year


Posted By: White70JavelinSST
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 8:38am
Viton is the same material that the space shuttles cargo bay doors were sealed with.

I bought polyurethane boots for the ball joints, 15 years later they're still doing a good job. That's about 30K miles. Moog ball joints from 15 years ago were still excellent quality.

I strongly suggest you do NOT use polyurethane strut rod bushings.
If you do use them, do NOT lift the car and leave the suspension at full droop.
 if you do use poly bushings,  only lift the front of the car one side at a time under the very end of the lower control arm so the suspension does not droop..


-------------
70 Javelin SST, second owner, purchased 1972


Posted By: bigbad69
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 8:43am
Originally posted by tomj tomj wrote:

... chinese made, that's not the problem, Q.C. is...
Certainly good quality parts can be made in China, or anywhere for that matter, if the manufacturer cares enough. Quality costs money and consumers, in general, buy by price first, quality second. Manufactures are responding in kind by supplying very cheap products that are crap.

Originally posted by FSJunkie FSJunkie wrote:

...3 year warranty...Lifetime warranty...
Don't conflate warranty and quality. Warranty is insurance, not a quality indicator.

I once had a NAPA counterman explain the difference between the one year warranty part and the lifetime warranty part. In fact, it was the exact same part (TRW), but the price was slightly higher to cover the extra take back on the lifetime part.

A warranty doesn't mean they don't think it will fail during the stated period, it means the actuaries have budgeted for a calculated number of failures and tacked that cost onto the price of the part. If you buy a part and it doesn't fail, you have lost money because you paid for someone else to be compensated for their part failure. In this respect, the above mentioned  three year warranty part is a better deal... if it doesn't fail.

Originally posted by Steve_P Steve_P wrote:

Moog is definitely not the quality it was 30 years ago...
I think that is true of pretty much every brand


-------------
69 Javelin SST BBO 390 T10


Posted By: Mopar_guy
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 9:47am
FWIW I would keep using any of the original tie rod ends and ball joints if they're still tight. Throwing them out for new is a waste of money. Most of the new stuff is less quality than the original stuff is. I've had good luck with Mevotech stuff in several vehicles after having Moog stuff fail. Moog is not the brand it once was. 

-------------

" http://theamcforum.com/forum/hemilina_topic95889.html" rel="nofollow - Hemilina " My 1973, 5.7 Hemi swapped Javelin


Posted By: Heavy 488
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 10:31am
Nothing wrong with keeping an old part as long as it's good. With steering parts, look for more than play. Grabbing it with your hands isn't exhibiting the same forces as driving. Take it loose and check for articulation. Any noticeable tight or loose spots?
Ive had good luck with Mevotech across 4 different vehicles. From tie rods to steering boxes.


Posted By: purple72Gremlin
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 10:40am
Moog does not have the quality.  Years ago they did.  Napa used to be good years ago as well. I dont like too many brands anymore because 90% have gone down in quality 


Posted By: CHAR
Date Posted: Feb/13/2020 at 2:00pm
Thanks for all the comments.  FYI Moog parts from Rockauto ala carte are $160 -ball joints, tie rods and sleeves and an idler arm bushing.  I havent disassembled the front end yet, just observed that all the bushings and boots are toast and are probable (maybe)original to the car.  So I just started planning what would it take to just redo it all.  I'll check the rod ends and see how they are.

Thanks for the tip on poly bushings for the forward struts.  I have a Prothane kit that came with the car with everything in it, front and rear, but I'll avoid the strut bushings if they cause too much stress or not enough movement.


-------------
72 Javelin SST P code 360/auto/AC/rear defrost /Go Pack/Polar White w blue cord interior.


Posted By: CamJam
Date Posted: Feb/14/2020 at 11:43pm

I just had an experience with one of the metal sleeves that goes inside the strut rod bushings being too long. It meant that there was still slop in the bushing when it was tightened down to the factory torque spec.  It would occasionally clunk when backing out of my driveway too.  I drove the car that way for over a year and my alignment guy only found it when he couldn't get enough caster dialed in on one side.  The answer was simply to cut the sleeve down. Not sure all this time later what brand it was, if it came that way from the bushing manufacturer or someone just grabbed the wrong sleeve during installation.  

Just make sure both halves of your strut rod bushings are fully compressed when you're done. One half of mine (two piece bushing) you could spin by hand, but just viewing it from the outside it looked to be properly compressed. Up on the rack, viewing from the inside, it was obvious that it wasn't.

Maybe someone here can tell us what the correct length of those sleeves should be.


-------------
'73 Javelin 360 (current project)
'72 Baja Bronze Javelin SST
'69 Big Bad Orange AMX (2018 Teague Heritage Award) SOLD



Posted By: rsrguy3
Date Posted: Feb/15/2020 at 4:25pm
I'm personally not a fan of the squeaky urethane stuff, but I was surprised after perusing the web that there are no polygraphite bushings, the PG bushings came on the screen in the 90's, any reason you guys can think of that I can't  find any for the 71 jav? 

-------------
javguy


Posted By: 304-dude
Date Posted: Feb/15/2020 at 4:36pm
I think the poly kit has the correct length steel sleeve for fitting poly bushings. I would not use the factory style steel sleeve. I modded my poly bushings, and used thick teflon washers to remove squeeks, while running dry. Zero maintenance. I still have a few washers, if your interested. Let me know, and I sort out my extras.. you'll need one per Poly bush. Many use just the front poly bush with rear being rubber.

-------------
71 Javelin SST body
390 69 crank, 70 block & heads
NASCAR SB2 rods & pistons
78 Jeep TH400 w/ 2.76 Low
50/50 Ford-AMC Suspension
79 F150 rear & 8.8 axles
Ford Racing 3.25 gears & 9" /w Detroit locker


Posted By: AMXRWB
Date Posted: Feb/15/2020 at 4:49pm
How many auto part stores did I buy lifetime warranty parts from over the years then they go broke and close.No more of that for me.


Posted By: PHAT69AMX
Date Posted: Feb/15/2020 at 10:37pm
Thumbs Up AMXRWB

-------------


Link to a http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MySiKQsmWxU" rel="nofollow - Short YouTube Burnout Video



Posted By: Mopar_guy
Date Posted: Feb/16/2020 at 7:09am
I forgot I had this article. http://www.suspension.com/blog/where-are-moog-parts-made/%20" rel="nofollow - https://www.suspension.com/blog/where-are-moog-parts-made/

As for lifetime warranties, if you have the receipt any any auto parts store can warranty it. I've had stuff go bad that I bought from Rock Auto and got it replaced locally.


-------------

" http://theamcforum.com/forum/hemilina_topic95889.html" rel="nofollow - Hemilina " My 1973, 5.7 Hemi swapped Javelin


Posted By: AMXRWB
Date Posted: Feb/16/2020 at 9:52am
No auto parts store in my area will take a warranty part from another store.The stores print the receipts with paper and ink that will disappear in a few years.Then they are blank.Gave up on that years ago.Great article on Moog.Politicians have made the taxes so high you need to move to another country.The latest is the internet tax.We can now all enjoy that for the rest of our life.


Posted By: Steve_P
Date Posted: Feb/18/2020 at 9:51am
Originally posted by AMXRWB AMXRWB wrote:

No auto parts store in my area will take a warranty part from another store.The stores print the receipts with paper and ink that will disappear in a few years.Then they are blank.Gave up on that years ago.Great article on Moog.Politicians have made the taxes so high you need to move to another country.The latest is the internet tax.We can now all enjoy that for the rest of our life.


Google the effective tax rates that most large US corporations pay. It is generally much lower than the stated rate because there are so many loopholes and deductions. And the corporate rate is now 21% to start with, so the jobs will come rushing back from China. Not


Posted By: agnt1967
Date Posted: Feb/26/2020 at 11:57am
I replaced a new Moog PS pitman arm purchased new in 2005, installed in 2006 and after 6 years and 2700 miles later, the pivot connection at the draglink was quite loose - at first I thought the nut was loose, but in fact the ball swivel was worn. I now try to find old parts stocks from 60s, 70s and early 80s. Just cannot trust anything anymore.


Posted By: FSJunkie
Date Posted: Feb/27/2020 at 1:51am
It's not just the composition of the strut rod bushings that matters, it's the shape of the bushing and it's washers.

Early one and two piece bushings are more or less simple doughnuts that don't deflect much. They transmit a lot of road noise and shock to the unit body structure that you hear and feel inside the car. Later two piece bushings (Concord, Spirit, Eagle) have a conical, tapered shape that deflects much more, up to about 3/8 inch. These bushings allow the wheels to actually move rearward when they encounter a bump, and they produce a much smoother and quieter ride. Bushings like this are exactly how Lincolns and Cadillacs achieved a smoother and quieter ride than Chevrolets and Fords. AMC did the same thing, only it was Concord verses Hornet.

Of course, the later conical strut rod bushings deflect more when the car is thrown into a hard corner and create mushy handling, but I don't care about that. I like a smooth, quiet ride as I drive straight down the highway listening to Vic Damone in stereo.


-------------
1955 Packard
1966 Marlin
1972 Wagoneer
1973 Ambassador
1977 Hornet
1982 Concord D/L
1984 Eagle Limited


Posted By: Buzzman72
Date Posted: Feb/27/2020 at 6:06am
Vic Damone....now THAT's a name you don't seem much anymore...

Like Steve Lawrence.


-------------
Buzzman72...void where prohibited, your mileage may vary, objects in mirror may be closer than they appear, and alcohol may intensify any side effects.


Posted By: JGRANTAMX
Date Posted: Feb/27/2020 at 10:20am
Do the later strut rod bushings from Concord, Eagle and Spirit  fit earlier cars?


Posted By: tomj
Date Posted: Feb/27/2020 at 11:45pm
Sheesh -- looking to buy strut bushings of the "modern" two-piece style, I can find no parts at all. I had Moog K3090, MyQuay-Norris (and others) FA685. No parts available.

Does anyone know of a part that is actually available?

This is maddening...



-------------
1960 Rambler Super two-door wagon, OHV auto
1961 Roadster American, 195.6 OHV, T5
http://www.ramblerLore.com



Posted By: 304-dude
Date Posted: Feb/28/2020 at 4:13am
APD, has them listed... haven't ordered as of recent to know if they are in stock. Usually such parts are available in late spring and summer. A lot of hard parts stuff is low stock in winter... at least when i am looking. Also RockAuto, seems to carry a wide selection, you might try there.

-------------
71 Javelin SST body
390 69 crank, 70 block & heads
NASCAR SB2 rods & pistons
78 Jeep TH400 w/ 2.76 Low
50/50 Ford-AMC Suspension
79 F150 rear & 8.8 axles
Ford Racing 3.25 gears & 9" /w Detroit locker


Posted By: tomj
Date Posted: Feb/29/2020 at 1:31am
Originally posted by Mopar_guy Mopar_guy wrote:

As for lifetime warranties,...

We all assumed the "lifetime" was of the part, or the buyer, not the seller! lol



-------------
1960 Rambler Super two-door wagon, OHV auto
1961 Roadster American, 195.6 OHV, T5
http://www.ramblerLore.com



Posted By: Trader
Date Posted: Feb/29/2020 at 6:46am
APD, Gavin's ... are all prothane that will give a harsher ride. I contacted Moog months ago and they stated they no longer make the rubber 2 piece strut rod bushings for AMC's but their "partners" did supply the prothane in red or black. Not only is the prothane a harsher ride, it puts a lot of stress on a strut rod not designed for it. Over the last few years I have seen more broken strut rods were prothane has been used. One caused a person to loose control and subsequently loose their Mustang, they were OK, just a few bruises.
Wanting rubber for this location I did this:
http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html" rel="nofollow - http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html




Posted By: tomj
Date Posted: Mar/01/2020 at 12:35am
Originally posted by Trader Trader wrote:

Wanting rubber for this location I did this:
http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html" rel="nofollow - http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html

Just re-read that, the multiple lengths business. I remember hacksawing the spacer to match the old. Or just use the old steel spacer, no big deal.

Yeah, you gotta be careful where and when with polyethylene, I'm with you here, strut bushings are no place for polyurethane on a street car. For such a simple-seeming part they've given me a lot of grief over the years. Inside the trunnion pivot on 68 American, fine, it's not in compression.

The parts-number, catalog collapse thing is terrible.  These part numbers may all fit, be the same, or one of the two different heights:

Moog K8157.
Mevotech MK8157. Says alternate number is K3090.
Moog K3090. No longer exists, but was in my notes from 10 years ago.
McQuay-Norris FA685. Seems to have disappeared.
Dorman 531-650.

What a mess.

...

I just went out to check my inventory... I have a half set of two two-piece types, with different inner-spacer lengths. I recall now that these were leftover from my working out half rubber/half poly solutions for the then-unavailable 63..66 strut bushing. I didn't mark them with part numbers, dumb. Original was one piece, but the strut itself has a swaged end, requires a short bushing, and cut-down rubber failed spectacularly.

63..66 solution:  http://www.sr-ix.com/AMC/Strut-bushing/index.html" rel="nofollow - http://www.sr-ix.com/AMC/Strut-bushing/index.html

That worked out OK, as far as I know it's still in that car. It's poly in front, not good, but it beats not having a bushing.


I made a page about the two-piece jobs, but it is, in hindsight, useless:  http://www.sr-ix.com/AMC/Strut-bushing/index.html" rel="nofollow - http://www.sr-ix.com/AMC/Strut-bushing/index.html


Since I'm about to re-do them in the 68 I'll see if I can pull this information together and post it with photos.




-------------
1960 Rambler Super two-door wagon, OHV auto
1961 Roadster American, 195.6 OHV, T5
http://www.ramblerLore.com



Posted By: 1982AMCConcord
Date Posted: Jul/23/2020 at 12:08pm
Originally posted by tomj tomj wrote:

Originally posted by Trader Trader wrote:

Wanting rubber for this location I did this:
http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html" rel="nofollow - http://theamcforum.com/forum/strut-rod-bushings_topic103832.html

Just re-read that, the multiple lengths business. I remember hacksawing the spacer to match the old. Or just use the old steel spacer, no big deal.

Yeah, you gotta be careful where and when with polyethylene, I'm with you here, strut bushings are no place for polyurethane on a street car. For such a simple-seeming part they've given me a lot of grief over the years. Inside the trunnion pivot on 68 American, fine, it's not in compression.

The parts-number, catalog collapse thing is terrible.  These part numbers may all fit, be the same, or one of the two different heights:

Moog K8157.
Mevotech MK8157. Says alternate number is K3090.
Moog K3090. No longer exists, but was in my notes from 10 years ago.
McQuay-Norris FA685. Seems to have disappeared.
Dorman 531-650.

What a mess.


So are these part numbers for Ford bushings that need to be modified? Correct?

I used Ploy on my car because... like everyone else... I couldn't find rubber ones.


Posted By: THE MENACE
Date Posted: Jul/23/2020 at 2:18pm
If/when I use poly bushings I (Whenever possible) I use the black Energy suspension bushings. The reason is their black bushings are made with a higher content of graphite than the other colors and if you use Teflon grease during assembly you will never hear them squeak.  

-------------
Former Owner of:
The Craig Breedlove "AERO AMX"

Still Owner:
SS/AMX #9 replica (THE BIG MENACE)
70 AMX 416, EFI, Nash 5 speed   
70 Javelin 401, 727 (Wife's car)
72 Gremlin Autocross Project.


Posted By: 1982AMCConcord
Date Posted: Jul/23/2020 at 3:19pm
Originally posted by THE MENACE THE MENACE wrote:

If/when I use poly bushings I (Whenever possible) I use the black Energy suspension bushings. The reason is their black bushings are made with a higher content of graphite than the other colors and if you use Teflon grease during assembly you will never hear them squeak.  


I read that and I unfortunately bought the red ones. I would like to switch them before this car start seeing road time. I did find these on Rock Auto for 1979 AMC Concord with 304 v8...

MAS BRK801000



Posted By: RSX 401
Date Posted: Jul/23/2020 at 3:34pm
Part Number  K3090 may not exist with Moog, but it still exist at O'Reilly Auto Parts under their own brand (Master Pro) and come with a Lifetime Warranty.



The one piece bushings, K3091 are also available from O'Reilly's.





-------------
I'll follow these lines a little ways more,

Until I can find what I'm looking for.

With the pedal to the metal,

I'm gaining my speed.

Riding down low in my AMC.....


Posted By: Mr_AMC
Date Posted: Aug/24/2020 at 2:31pm
THAT is awesome


Posted By: Cholo
Date Posted: Sep/23/2020 at 12:57pm
Originally posted by RSX 401 RSX 401 wrote:

Part Number  K3090 may not exist with Moog, but it still exist at O'Reilly Auto Parts under their own brand (Master Pro) and come with a Lifetime Warranty.



The one piece bushings, K3091 are also available from O'Reilly's.




Thanks! Just ordered a set. Will see how they work out.


-------------
Cholo! For the 6.


Posted By: green70AMX
Date Posted: Feb/12/2021 at 8:45am
I know this is an older post but exactly how do theses Master Pro Strut rod bushing assemble? where does the cup piece go? thanks  Bob

-------------
green70AMX


Posted By: XJ6
Date Posted: Feb/12/2021 at 9:59am
Originally posted by 1982AMCConcord 1982AMCConcord wrote:

Originally posted by THE MENACE THE MENACE wrote:

If/when I use poly bushings I (Whenever possible) I use the black Energy suspension bushings. The reason is their black bushings are made with a higher content of graphite than the other colors and if you use Teflon grease during assembly you will never hear them squeak.  


I read that and I unfortunately bought the red ones. I would like to switch them before this car start seeing road time. I did find these on Rock Auto for 1979 AMC Concord with 304 v8...

MAS BRK801000



Throw the teflon grease in the trash. Use a a heavy graphite/moly paste when assembling and wont matter what color the bushings are.


Posted By: green70AMX
Date Posted: Feb/12/2021 at 4:07pm
Was hoping for what order the moog bushing pieces go know where rubber and concave washers go but where does the cup looking piece go and is it fwd or aft of the bracket. Thanks bob

-------------
green70AMX



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.03 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2019 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net